Skip To...
Although the court of justice has given the Menendez brothers a chance, the court of public opinion still dissects their lives. Erik and Lyle Menendez have turned the tide of their case. The brothers have now been resentenced to 50 years to life on Tuesday. The Menendez brothers were convicted of first-degree murder for killing both parents in their home in 1989. Following the new ruling, the brothers are eligible for parole and may gain freedom soon. Judge Michael Jesic was shocked by the brothers’ horrific crime and the supportive letters from prison. The judge noted that corrections officers gave sterling remarks regarding the brothers’ behavior in jail.
The brothers appeared remotely from prison, expressing profound remorse and taking full responsibility for their actions. Erik acknowledged the profound sadness he caused his family and said there is no justification for his actions. He committed to making a positive difference, whether in or out of prison. Lyle admitted to the killings, attributing them to immaturity and rage. He shared that he did not seek help due to his belief that no one would believe his story. He expressed a desire to support sexual abuse victims if reintegrated into society.
Jesic stated that, while they are eligible for parole, he is not advocating for their immediate release. However, he believes they should eventually have the opportunity for parole. The decision ultimately rests with the state parole board and the governor. Per CNN, a hearing is now scheduled for June 13 as part of a separate appeal by the brothers.
Questions Trail the Menendez Brothers’ Resentencing
Since the verdict, opinions have remained divided on whether the brothers deserve their new normal. Basically, some faction are against the verdict, while others are fully behind the brothers. A curious X user asked, “Honestly, this case still gives me chills. They’ve been through so much, but the question is, do they deserve a second chance?” One more user expressed how interesting the situation is, stressing that “the algorithm is undefeated.” Another commenter criticized those who thought the resentencing was a good idea.
A fourth commenter argued that they “should both be rotting in jail until their last breaths.” This X subscriber is convinced the brothers “can’t even admit what they did.” More sentiments reflect a deep sympathy for Erik and Lyle, viewing them as innocent victims of their upbringing. There is a strong belief that they deserve freedom after enduring a lifetime in prison. Another X user also reechoed the overwhelming clamour for their release, tagging them “innocent.” The commenter emphasized the importance of prayer and support for their long-awaited freedom.
L.A. District Attorney Argued Against the Menendez Brothers’ Freedom
We earlier shared that Nathan Hochman emerged as a significant barrier to the Menendez Brothers’ release from prison bid. In his opposition to their parole bid, Hochman drew a comparison between the brothers and Sirhan Sirhan, the assassin of Robert F. Kennedy. He argued that both should be denied freedom, as Sirhan displayed the same pattern as the Menendez brothers.
Hochman explained that Sirhan initially confessed to the murder but later claimed innocence and memory loss. Despite Sirhan’s attempts for parole, Governor Gavin Newsom denied his request. Newsom took a different approach regarding Erik and Lyle Menendez by supporting their quest for parole. He sent their case to the parole board for a risk assessment.
Hochman’s efforts to block the resentencing of the Menendez brothers faced several criticisms. Some commentators questioned the fairness of his comparisons, suggesting that the two cases are not truly comparable. They pointed out that, unlike Sirhan, the Menendez Brothers had experienced abuse. Supporters of the brothers have voiced their belief that they should be granted release.
Now that a resentencing has happened, will freedom come early for the Menendez brothers?
